Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur McArthur
Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur Logo

Mama Renie's Pizza of mcarthur

4.51263 reviews

Nestled in McArthur, Mama Renie's Pizza offers a cozy spot for comfort food lovers. This pizzeria serves delicious dishes, ranging from classic pizzas to unique local specialties. With a welcoming atmosphere, it's ideal for family gatherings, casual dining, or a quick bite after outdoor adventures.

The restaurant features a vibrant decor that reflects local charm. You'll feel at home with friendly service and an inviting vibe. Mama Renie's focuses on hearty meals that satisfy every craving, day or night, from mouthwatering breakfasts to late-night pizzas. It's perfect for anyone looking to enjoy a relaxed meal.

About

Mama Renie's Pizza has become a beloved staple in McArthur. Located at 100 W Main St, it's positioned perfectly for locals and travelers. Open since early morning, it provides a warm spot for breakfast enthusiasts. The restaurant captures the essence of small-town friendliness and community spirit, making it a favorite meet-up spot.

Over the years, Mama Renie's has built a reputation for serving hearty, home-style meals. Many come not just for the food, but also for the connection it fosters. With a mixture of local flavors and classic pizzeria favorites, the menu draws in people from all walks of life. It's more than just a meal; it's an experience steeped in community and heart.

Get in Touch

100 W Main St, McArthur, OH 45651, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 07:00-22:00
  • Tuesday 07:00-22:00
  • Wednesday 07:00-22:00
  • Thursday 07:00-22:00
  • Friday 07:00-22:00
  • Saturday 07:00-23:00
  • Sunday 07:00-23:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Maybe it was just because we went mid-week, but the atmosphere was almost too quiet -- quiet enough that talking felt a little awkward, like everyone could hear us. Some background music would definitely help bring the place to life. That said, the food more than made up for the silence. It came out a little slow, but absolutely worth the wait. I was already more than halfway through an 18" pizza by myself before my husband pointed it out, and honestly, I have no regrets. I also decided to try the pickle pizza simply because it sounded so odd, and I'm so glad I did. I ended up falling in love with something I never knew I needed in my life. It's a must-try, and I'll 100% be going back just for that alone. As for value, the price for an appetizer, an 18" pizza, a 7" pizza, a 12" sub, two desserts, and two drinks was surprisingly reasonable. Between the quality, the portions, and the unique flavors, it's definitely a place that we'll be returning to."

- Sunny

"Omg... the food is incredible. Best cheese burger ever, stacked high with veggies. Eat those fries with mayo and vinegar..mmmmmm and thin crust pizza and fried pickles better than any place I have been. 5stars... I do miss our original waitress but service is good as well."

- Me B.

"We stopped at Mama Renies after a long day of hiking at Moonville and it was great. Had two kids with us, wasn't at all a problem. The pizza was awesome, really enjoyed the buffalo chicken. Prices are very reasonable. All in all a really excellent little pizza and tavern right in the heart of McArthur."

- Nick J.

"Stopped in on the way home from a soccer game. Small town but I must admit, good food. We enjoyed all we had. Service was fantastic with a server that had a smile for us and was friendly and quick. Would definitely stop in again if in the area."

- Jeff W.

"Very good food, and the people are normally very friendly! Don't love the atmosphere with the kids, and sometimes it smells kinda bad inside. Just order take out and it's always delicious."

- Hannah B.

"Went in today for the first time never even heard of this village town seen the sign for it on way back home from hocking hills! and the name caught my attention! Me and my friend ordered calzones best calzone i have ever ate in my life great service the waitress there are both pretty and sweet would recommend to anyone!"

- Kristen Y.
Write a Review

Why Visit

When in McArthur, Mama Renie's Pizza is a must-visit. Its menu showcases a fantastic array of pizzas, including standouts like the famous pickle pizza—perfect for adventurous eaters. The restaurant also offers a full bar, featuring a great selection of beers. Enjoying a meal with a beverage adds to the experience.

Tips for visiting? Arrive early for breakfast on weekends; the pancakes and omelettes are popular. Lunchtime brings a busy crowd, so consider getting takeout if you're short on time. If dining in, savor the relaxing vibe while watching local sports on TV. It's a great place to unwind after a hike or day of exploring.

Another reason to visit is the affordability. Plates are reasonably priced with generous portions. Share a multi-course meal or enjoy a solo feast; either way, the value stands out. The combination of friendly service and delicious food makes Mama Renie's an essential stop whether you're a local or just passing through.

Most Liked things

The standout dishes draw the most admiration from patrons. Many rave about the thin-crust pizza and unique flavors, especially the pickle pizza. Visitors appreciate the variety of local beers and the homemade desserts, like the decadent chocolate spoon cake. Family-friendly service makes it welcoming to groups.

Most Disliked things

Some guests mention the quieter atmosphere, especially during mid-week visits. A few think it could benefit from more background music to enhance the dining experience. A minority share concerns about occasional slow service during peak hours. Overall, most feel the positive aspects outweigh any minor reservations.

FAQ

What type of food is served at Mama Renie's Pizza of McArthur?

Mama Renie's offers a diverse menu. Enjoy pizzas, subs, sandwiches, salads, and appetizers. Specialties include the Bacon Cheeseburger pizza and the Buffalo Chicken Salad. There’s something for everyone.

Is there a delivery service available?

Yes, Mama Renie's has contactless delivery options. You can also opt for takeout if you prefer to enjoy your meal at home without waiting.

What are the payment options at this location?

Mama Renie's accepts various payment methods. Credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments are all accepted. It's convenient and easy to settle your bill.

Are there any accessible facilities for guests with mobility challenges?

Yes, Mama Renie's is wheelchair accessible. The entrance, seating areas, and restrooms accommodate guests with mobility challenges.