The menu at Mama Renie's Pizza is extensive. From appetizers to desserts, there’s something for everyone. Popular appetizers include pickle fries and spicy cheese bites, perfect for sharing. The specialty pizzas, like the BBQ chicken and meat lovers, are crowd favorites.
The restaurant also offers hearty entrees such as the New York strip steak and buffalo chicken salad. For kids, special menu items ensure everyone finds something delicious. Don't miss dessert, with choices like brownie pizza cookie and NY-style cheesecake. Each dish reflects the commitment to quality and taste that defines Mama Renie's.
Featured Dishes

Pepperoni Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza

Fish Sandwich

Country Fried Chicken

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

Grand Champion Burger

Pepperoni Mushroom and Extra Cheese Pizza

Turkey Bacon Ranch

All Meat Lovers Pizza Wirh Onions

Cheese Burger

Viking Burger with Fries

Mild Chicken Wings

Loaded French Fries and Turkey Bacon Club

Italian Sub

Chicken Salad on Croissant

Crispy Bacon
Discover Mama Renie's Pizza of McArthur, your go-to pizzeria located at 100 W Main St, McArthur, OH. Enjoy a casual dining experience featuring a vast selection of local specialties and a great choice of beers. We offer contactless delivery, takeout, and dine-in options, making it perfect for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. With wheelchair accessibility and a relaxed atmosphere, we cater to everyone from solo diners to groups. Relax and catch the game while savoring our traditional cuisine, cocktails, and late-night bites. Join us for an unforgettable meal—reservations are accepted! Call us today at +1 740-596-3300.